Stepping off the plane in Chisinau for the first time in 2years, I immediately felt a mixture of nervous emotions mixed with elation. Luckily, somehow playing the role of semi-tourguide helped to suppress both sides of my initial reaction. I still haven’t fully processed the whole experience, but maybe by the time I’m done writing this blog entry I’ll have a better idea of how I feel about it.
This trip to Moldova was to help prepare a January Term course that will be offered through the Harvard School of Public Health. The course will take 15 Harvard graduate students from different programs to London, Italy and Moldova to study the humanitarian response to human trafficking. The course will be looking at London as an example of a destination country, Italy as a point of transit (as well as destination) and Moldova as a basic example of a source country. Our assignment on this trip was to identify organizations, individuals and government agencies with whom the students could meet in January.
Alia and Anaide—the two fabulous women in charge of the logistics for the J-term course—were delightful company in Moldova. We walked outside and found our driver, Constantin, waiting for us. After we arrived at the Hotel, we got changed and left almost immediately for the 4th of July party. It was strange being at the annual party for the 4th time but first time not as a Peace Corps volunteer. I saw all the PCVs but only recognized a couple of them from the training group that I worked with right before leaving for Belize. We met up with Vika who was a great help in sorting out a driver and helping us with other small logistical questions.
“Work” started on Sunday with a tour of the wine cellars at Cricova…but the real work started after the tour with our first interview and then went non-stop until Friday afternoon. Each day we had up to 5meetings with NGOs, Gov’t officials, journalists, doctors, lawyers, etc. who are involved either directly or tangentially with the issue of human trafficking in Moldova. About half the meetings needed translation from Romanian/Russian into English. It was a definitely a test of my language skills, and of course, with the Russian we called in extra help.
At the end of every day we had to debrief the meetings, recording the take-aways, gaps, tensions, and general observations. In general, the process taught me an extraordinary level of respect for field researchers—and also convinced me it may not be a path I’d necessarily choose for myself in life. Although, as Alia gently pointed out, it may have just been difficult for me given my highly emotional connection with Moldova.
For me, the two most impressive meetings were towards the end of the week. On Thursday evening we met with a lawyer who takes on multiple human trafficking cases each year pro-bono. It was very clear that, for her, it was an effort straight from her heart—but also that it had really affected her, she was at times seemingly paranoid even to be discussing the topic in public. On Friday afternoon, our very last meeting of the week was with an organization that runs a shelter for female victims of trafficking, specifically targeting women with children or who are pregnant. The people who run this shelter truly inspired me and I hope to somehow maintain communication with them and find ways to support their work.
It was difficult for me to not automatically put all the interviews into a cultural lens of my background with Moldova—and I really appreciated the debriefing sessions with Alia and Anaide who were able to keep things on a purely analytical level, helping me to put an emotional distance between myself and the stories we’d heard each day.
Because the students are supposed to experience everything first-hand, without the influence of a third-party filter, I don’t think I can write in too much detail the conclusions I reached at the end of the week. However, I think it suffices to say that I am beyond grateful that I had the opportunity to be part of this trip, and I look forward to the projects/reports that the students develop. I truly believe it can be a help to Moldova and to the people working there to end human trafficking.
Zan in Vienna: Interning for the United Nations Global Initiative to Fight Human Trafficking (UNGIFT)
Tuesday, July 12, 2011
Giving a Shout out to the 12 Small Grant Recipients
UN.GIFT piloted its Small Grants program in 2009, with recipient projects having an implementation period in fiscal year 2010-2011. This week I was asked to use the interim reports from the 12 recipient organizations to assess the outcomes of the program.
I know I’m not supposed to have favorites, but my favorite by far was Solidarites—a Brazilian NGO who worked with victims of trafficking to help them tell their stories. Despite being printed in Portuguese, I dedicated the translation time (thank goodness for google translate) in order to read the report on the situation of women in Brazil that was written by the victims themselves. Its difficult to say that Solidarites is my favorite, because the work being done by all 12 organizations is phenomenal.
The broad range of approaches to awareness raising, prevention, legal aid, and direct victim assistance was interesting for me to read through. It seems that despite major differences in culture, region, and organizational structure, that there are common threads between the success stories.
Some of the common threads: economic and emotional empowerment of at-risk individuals and victims; collaboration and transparency with law enforcement; distribution of materials in order to raise awareness of available services, etc.
Unfortunately, it seems that each of these organizations relies nearly exclusively on external donations and questions of sustainability do not seem to be a priority.
I know I’m not supposed to have favorites, but my favorite by far was Solidarites—a Brazilian NGO who worked with victims of trafficking to help them tell their stories. Despite being printed in Portuguese, I dedicated the translation time (thank goodness for google translate) in order to read the report on the situation of women in Brazil that was written by the victims themselves. Its difficult to say that Solidarites is my favorite, because the work being done by all 12 organizations is phenomenal.
The broad range of approaches to awareness raising, prevention, legal aid, and direct victim assistance was interesting for me to read through. It seems that despite major differences in culture, region, and organizational structure, that there are common threads between the success stories.
Some of the common threads: economic and emotional empowerment of at-risk individuals and victims; collaboration and transparency with law enforcement; distribution of materials in order to raise awareness of available services, etc.
Unfortunately, it seems that each of these organizations relies nearly exclusively on external donations and questions of sustainability do not seem to be a priority.
OSCE Conference on Human Trafficking
As part of my internship with UN.GIFT, I had the opportunity to attend the OSCE’s 11th annual Conference on Combating Human Trafficking. Over 300 member-state delegates, NGO representatives, academics, and law enforcement officials attended the conference in the Hofburg in Vienna.
I had no idea what to expect when I arrived in the first session, put on my translation headphones and opened my notebook to take notes. Two days later, I left feeling unclear on the purpose of the conference, but with a peaked interest on specific topics…and with lots of Spanish practice (having set my headset to Spanish to make the long sessions more interesting.)
The unclear bit: it seemed that it was such a huge opportunity to produce some kind of clear outcome—yet, ultimately at the end of the two days everyone simply said goodbye and went home. I remain curious why there wasn’t break-out sessions to produce a list of best practices or some sort of joint statement, or SOMETHING…It was likely the largest gathering of people at all levels in the fight against human trafficking, yet a large majority of the conference was spent making vague political statements rather than solid discussion of methods that produce success, common challenges, etc.
The bit that peaked my interest: A theme throughout the conference was a call for data-driven programming. It seemed that everyone agreed that there needed to be a more strategic approach to combating trafficking and that key to this would be having better ways of measuring outcomes.
Overall I was really glad that I attended the conference, and very happy to have made contacts with amazingly inspirational individuals who have worked in the field since before the Palermo Protocol.
I had no idea what to expect when I arrived in the first session, put on my translation headphones and opened my notebook to take notes. Two days later, I left feeling unclear on the purpose of the conference, but with a peaked interest on specific topics…and with lots of Spanish practice (having set my headset to Spanish to make the long sessions more interesting.)
The unclear bit: it seemed that it was such a huge opportunity to produce some kind of clear outcome—yet, ultimately at the end of the two days everyone simply said goodbye and went home. I remain curious why there wasn’t break-out sessions to produce a list of best practices or some sort of joint statement, or SOMETHING…It was likely the largest gathering of people at all levels in the fight against human trafficking, yet a large majority of the conference was spent making vague political statements rather than solid discussion of methods that produce success, common challenges, etc.
The bit that peaked my interest: A theme throughout the conference was a call for data-driven programming. It seemed that everyone agreed that there needed to be a more strategic approach to combating trafficking and that key to this would be having better ways of measuring outcomes.
Overall I was really glad that I attended the conference, and very happy to have made contacts with amazingly inspirational individuals who have worked in the field since before the Palermo Protocol.
Wednesday, June 15, 2011
The Harvard Research Program on Humanitarian Response to Human Trafficking
This is the link to the project's website:
http://www.hpcrresearch.org/research/human-trafficking
I'm working on the UN.GIFT coordination end :) which is a great opportunity for me to link what I'm doing here in Vienna with ongoing research back in Cambridge.
Alia and Anaide are both amazing, and if you want to keep updated on all their efforts, you can follow Alia on twitter.
http://www.hpcrresearch.org/research/human-trafficking
I'm working on the UN.GIFT coordination end :) which is a great opportunity for me to link what I'm doing here in Vienna with ongoing research back in Cambridge.
Alia and Anaide are both amazing, and if you want to keep updated on all their efforts, you can follow Alia on twitter.
2011 Special Rapporteur on trafficking presents 2011 report
Ms. Joy Ngozi Ezeilo, in her role as the U.N. Special Rapporteur on trafficking in persons, released her latest report which covers the period from 1 March 2010 to 1 March 2011. This report includes an overview of the activities undertaken by the Special Rapporteur as well as an analysis of an effective remedy for trafficked persons.
In February 2011, UN.GIFT, OHCHR and the Office of the Special Rapporteur launched an online forum in the UN.GIFT.HUB to solicit views and comments on the on the right to an effective remedy for trafficked persons. More than 40 experts gathered on the UN.GIFT.HUB's forum to exchange their views on the "draft basic principles on the right to an effective remedy for trafficked persons" .
The participants included specialists from international and civil society organizations and academic institutions around the world. The participants discussed a variety of topics, including remedies for trafficked children, the notion of "restitution" in the context of trafficked persons, and gender-related barriers to access to justice for trafficked women.
The outcome of the UN.GIFT forum was reflected on the final report. A summary note of the discussions is available online at the UN.GIFT.HUB's forum.
Summary of the SR Report
In the report, the Special Rapporteur clearly establishes the concept of an effective remedy as a human right, outlining the international legal framework of this right and what it entails in the specific context of trafficked persons. Also she focuses on what special factors need to be considered in realizing this right particularly for trafficked children.
As part of the final chapter of the report, and as part of her conclusions and recommendations, the Special Rapporteur submitted the "draft basic principles on the right to an effective remedy for trafficked persons, contained in annex I to the present report."
Main Highlights of the Report:
"Found that despite the fundamental guarantee of the right to an effective remedy under international law, there remains a large gap in practice between legal provisions and their implementation in relation to trafficked persons."
Emphasized that despite the fact that most human trafficking is the act of individuals or private organizations, that States share in the responsibility of the crime if it "failed to take necessary measures to prevent the effects of the conduct of private parties".
Cautioned that "simply returning the trafficked person to the pre-existing situation may place him or her at the risk of further human rights violations and being re-trafficked."
An analysis of key components of a victim's right to an effective remedy, "including restitution, recovery, compensation, satisfaction and guarantees of non-repetition, access to information, legal assistance, and regularization of residence status."
Read the Full Report in the UN.GIFT.HUB Resource Centre
In February 2011, UN.GIFT, OHCHR and the Office of the Special Rapporteur launched an online forum in the UN.GIFT.HUB to solicit views and comments on the on the right to an effective remedy for trafficked persons. More than 40 experts gathered on the UN.GIFT.HUB's forum to exchange their views on the "draft basic principles on the right to an effective remedy for trafficked persons" .
The participants included specialists from international and civil society organizations and academic institutions around the world. The participants discussed a variety of topics, including remedies for trafficked children, the notion of "restitution" in the context of trafficked persons, and gender-related barriers to access to justice for trafficked women.
The outcome of the UN.GIFT forum was reflected on the final report. A summary note of the discussions is available online at the UN.GIFT.HUB's forum.
Summary of the SR Report
In the report, the Special Rapporteur clearly establishes the concept of an effective remedy as a human right, outlining the international legal framework of this right and what it entails in the specific context of trafficked persons. Also she focuses on what special factors need to be considered in realizing this right particularly for trafficked children.
As part of the final chapter of the report, and as part of her conclusions and recommendations, the Special Rapporteur submitted the "draft basic principles on the right to an effective remedy for trafficked persons, contained in annex I to the present report."
Main Highlights of the Report:
"Found that despite the fundamental guarantee of the right to an effective remedy under international law, there remains a large gap in practice between legal provisions and their implementation in relation to trafficked persons."
Emphasized that despite the fact that most human trafficking is the act of individuals or private organizations, that States share in the responsibility of the crime if it "failed to take necessary measures to prevent the effects of the conduct of private parties".
Cautioned that "simply returning the trafficked person to the pre-existing situation may place him or her at the risk of further human rights violations and being re-trafficked."
An analysis of key components of a victim's right to an effective remedy, "including restitution, recovery, compensation, satisfaction and guarantees of non-repetition, access to information, legal assistance, and regularization of residence status."
Read the Full Report in the UN.GIFT.HUB Resource Centre
Friday, June 10, 2011
First Week of Work
IMPRESSIONS:
The more I learn about the behind the scenes workings of UN.GIFT, the more I am impressed by the fact that the whole organization is run by just 5 women...but not just any 5 women, 5 of the most passionate and dedicated women I've ever had the pleasure of meeting. The most impressive part is the amount of programming and publications they produce considering their exceptionally limited budget.
The budget is one thing that I think I often forget when I think about U.N. agencies...with all the huge impressive buildings and all the talk about large projects and initiative...I forget that a large part of each agency's work is essentially fundraising. Constantly looking for U.N. member countries to pledge financial support for their work.
In practice, despite being a part of the U.N., GIFT functions essentially as an NGO, struggling to complete major objectives with a small staff and an even smaller budget. Their accomplishments and commitment to the cause,in light of this, are humbling.
FINDING MY PLACE:
As with any new position, the first few days were slow and somewhat unclear as to what my role would be with UN.GIFT; and, me, being me...was a bit impatient to start out running! Now, a week in, I feel I've found my place (for the most part) and a good pace of work.
I'm mainly working on three things:
1. Helping coordinate the UN.GIFT and Harvard joint initiative to set-up a field research course on human trafficking that will travel to Moldova in January 2012!!!! This means I get to go with the two course assistants to Moldova the first week of July to set up the logistics of the course. It also means that I've been making phone calls to Moldova this week setting up the meetings for July, and its been so much fun remembering my Romanian and hearing some familiar and some new Moldovan voices. I'm really excited about the potential impact of a joint-Harvard and UN report on trafficking in Moldova.
2. Manage and update web content, especially focusing on recent publications, events and success stories from NGOs and Governments worldwide on anti-human trafficking efforts. This is a great opportunity for me to learn basic web-design and also to be continually up-to-date on all the latest happenings in the field. You can check out the site, and nearly everything posted/updated after June.3rd is me! www.ungift.org
Also, as a part of this, I'm going to be attending the OSCE international conference on human trafficking June 20-21; at which, I'll be responsible for interviewing as many participating organizations as possible to do a full online news feature series. I'm still trying to figure out how to work the voice recorder...eek.
3. This one is a keep fingers crossed that it all falls into place...UN.GIFT and the Carr Center for Human Rights (at the Kennedy School) are hoping to coordinate a year-long webinar series on human trafficking. All the kinks haven't yet been worked out, but if it gets sorted out, then I'll be helping to set the agenda/curriculm for the series.
SETTLING IN SOCIALLY
There is a very active intern community at the U.N. building, and they are all so much fun! I feel similar to my first few weeks at the Kennedy school--simply amazed at the backgrounds and experiences of the people I meet. All the interns (regardless of what agency they work for) are assigned desks in intern office space. I have 5 other interns in my office--four of whom are either recent law school grads or current law students. A French lawyer working with the UNODC on anti-drug trafficking, a Canadian lawyer turned social worker also working with UNODC but on drug prevention and treatment, an American law student (2L) working with UNODC on public private partnerships in the fight against drugs, a Polish lawyer working on inputting human-trafficking case-law into a new database that will be launched hopefully in August, and then the only other non-lawyer, a Lebonese masters student studying international security/counter-terrorism who is working on a counter-corruption/counter-human trafficking training program for law enforcement officials.
It seems crazy that we are all "interns", which I still associate with being an undergrad fetching coffee and making copies...but its amazing the people I get to be around every day. Its nice also, since we are all foreigners here and usually only for 3-6months, so we automatically bond and there is an immediate social network, which I truly hope will last beyond the summer.
The more I learn about the behind the scenes workings of UN.GIFT, the more I am impressed by the fact that the whole organization is run by just 5 women...but not just any 5 women, 5 of the most passionate and dedicated women I've ever had the pleasure of meeting. The most impressive part is the amount of programming and publications they produce considering their exceptionally limited budget.
The budget is one thing that I think I often forget when I think about U.N. agencies...with all the huge impressive buildings and all the talk about large projects and initiative...I forget that a large part of each agency's work is essentially fundraising. Constantly looking for U.N. member countries to pledge financial support for their work.
In practice, despite being a part of the U.N., GIFT functions essentially as an NGO, struggling to complete major objectives with a small staff and an even smaller budget. Their accomplishments and commitment to the cause,in light of this, are humbling.
FINDING MY PLACE:
As with any new position, the first few days were slow and somewhat unclear as to what my role would be with UN.GIFT; and, me, being me...was a bit impatient to start out running! Now, a week in, I feel I've found my place (for the most part) and a good pace of work.
I'm mainly working on three things:
1. Helping coordinate the UN.GIFT and Harvard joint initiative to set-up a field research course on human trafficking that will travel to Moldova in January 2012!!!! This means I get to go with the two course assistants to Moldova the first week of July to set up the logistics of the course. It also means that I've been making phone calls to Moldova this week setting up the meetings for July, and its been so much fun remembering my Romanian and hearing some familiar and some new Moldovan voices. I'm really excited about the potential impact of a joint-Harvard and UN report on trafficking in Moldova.
2. Manage and update web content, especially focusing on recent publications, events and success stories from NGOs and Governments worldwide on anti-human trafficking efforts. This is a great opportunity for me to learn basic web-design and also to be continually up-to-date on all the latest happenings in the field. You can check out the site, and nearly everything posted/updated after June.3rd is me! www.ungift.org
Also, as a part of this, I'm going to be attending the OSCE international conference on human trafficking June 20-21; at which, I'll be responsible for interviewing as many participating organizations as possible to do a full online news feature series. I'm still trying to figure out how to work the voice recorder...eek.
3. This one is a keep fingers crossed that it all falls into place...UN.GIFT and the Carr Center for Human Rights (at the Kennedy School) are hoping to coordinate a year-long webinar series on human trafficking. All the kinks haven't yet been worked out, but if it gets sorted out, then I'll be helping to set the agenda/curriculm for the series.
SETTLING IN SOCIALLY
There is a very active intern community at the U.N. building, and they are all so much fun! I feel similar to my first few weeks at the Kennedy school--simply amazed at the backgrounds and experiences of the people I meet. All the interns (regardless of what agency they work for) are assigned desks in intern office space. I have 5 other interns in my office--four of whom are either recent law school grads or current law students. A French lawyer working with the UNODC on anti-drug trafficking, a Canadian lawyer turned social worker also working with UNODC but on drug prevention and treatment, an American law student (2L) working with UNODC on public private partnerships in the fight against drugs, a Polish lawyer working on inputting human-trafficking case-law into a new database that will be launched hopefully in August, and then the only other non-lawyer, a Lebonese masters student studying international security/counter-terrorism who is working on a counter-corruption/counter-human trafficking training program for law enforcement officials.
It seems crazy that we are all "interns", which I still associate with being an undergrad fetching coffee and making copies...but its amazing the people I get to be around every day. Its nice also, since we are all foreigners here and usually only for 3-6months, so we automatically bond and there is an immediate social network, which I truly hope will last beyond the summer.
Wednesday, June 1, 2011
Arrived Safely in Vienna
Okay, I know I should post a substantive blog soon, but not much has happened as far as the internship goes (since today was my first day.)
I arrived safely in Vienna last night after a very long journey. I unpacked just what I needed for my first day at work, took a shower and went straight to sleep. This morning I was met outside the BEAUTIFUL UN building by the outgoing UNGIFT intern who acted as my tour guide all day. I didn't do anything substantive...but I have a badge, desk, computer login, phone line extension (wowser!), etc.
Three amazing things about work:
1. Just sitting back in the cafeteria to listen to all the languages simultaneously happening around me while I eat my UN price controlled salad (only 2.90)
2. They offer FREE, yes FREE, language classes in all the official UN languages...I'm signing up for Russian to actually learn it and Spanish to improve (I know this will make all Spanish native-speaking friends happy)Although, doing the two simultaneously will probably lower the possibility of losing my Russian accent when I speak Spanish.
3. UNGIFT only has 5 full-time staff....for those of you who haven't had the unique pleasure of being an intern, small staff=intern's being assigned ACTUAL substantive work.
Three amazing things about personal life:
1. My flat: basically is exactly what I have always dreamt of living in, in my dreams in which I'm living anywhere in Europe. Its funky, kinda old and definitely creaky, with really strange decor and huge windows looking out on beautiful architecture and a cobblestone street. Pictures soon to come...
2. My flatmates: Both within one year of my age, one is a law student in her final year (finishing exams right now, with the crazed look in her eye to prove it); the other a guy art student finishing his masters who has the tiniest bedroom but makes it feel huge because he built a loft for his queen bed and then put a fullsize couch and an armchair underneath.
3. 15minute commute to work. Enough said.
Okay, thats about it for now--I'm off for a night out with my flatmates!
I arrived safely in Vienna last night after a very long journey. I unpacked just what I needed for my first day at work, took a shower and went straight to sleep. This morning I was met outside the BEAUTIFUL UN building by the outgoing UNGIFT intern who acted as my tour guide all day. I didn't do anything substantive...but I have a badge, desk, computer login, phone line extension (wowser!), etc.
Three amazing things about work:
1. Just sitting back in the cafeteria to listen to all the languages simultaneously happening around me while I eat my UN price controlled salad (only 2.90)
2. They offer FREE, yes FREE, language classes in all the official UN languages...I'm signing up for Russian to actually learn it and Spanish to improve (I know this will make all Spanish native-speaking friends happy)Although, doing the two simultaneously will probably lower the possibility of losing my Russian accent when I speak Spanish.
3. UNGIFT only has 5 full-time staff....for those of you who haven't had the unique pleasure of being an intern, small staff=intern's being assigned ACTUAL substantive work.
Three amazing things about personal life:
1. My flat: basically is exactly what I have always dreamt of living in, in my dreams in which I'm living anywhere in Europe. Its funky, kinda old and definitely creaky, with really strange decor and huge windows looking out on beautiful architecture and a cobblestone street. Pictures soon to come...
2. My flatmates: Both within one year of my age, one is a law student in her final year (finishing exams right now, with the crazed look in her eye to prove it); the other a guy art student finishing his masters who has the tiniest bedroom but makes it feel huge because he built a loft for his queen bed and then put a fullsize couch and an armchair underneath.
3. 15minute commute to work. Enough said.
Okay, thats about it for now--I'm off for a night out with my flatmates!
Subscribe to:
Posts (Atom)